Bulletin n. 1/2015 | ||
June 2015 | ||
Evans Adam |
||
Back to the Future? Warnings from History for a Future UK Constitutional Convention | ||
in Political Quarterly , Volume 86, Issue 1, January–March 2015 , 2015 , 24–32 | ||
The full text is free: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1467-923X.12135/abstract Abstract Amid the fallout from the Scottish independence referendum, a UK constitutional convention has been proposed as a mechanism to take stock not only of the referendum, but also of the past fifteen years of devolution. However, despite longstanding conceptions of British constitutional development, a constitutional convention would not herald a brave new world for the UK's constitution. As the article highlights, in the past hundred years there have been two attempts to treat the territorial constitution in the round: the Speaker's Conference on Devolution, 1919–1920 and the Royal Commission on the Constitution, 1969–1973. This article examines both of these forums, arguing that they provide clear warnings for a future UK constitutional convention, in particular the threat of internal division that any such forum risks facing. A danger that this article highlights is heightened by the associated difficulty of reaching agreement across the UK's ‘state of unions’. | ||