Bulletin n. 1/2005 | ||
December 2005 | ||
Kehaulani Kauanui J. |
||
The multiplicity of Hawaiian sovereignty claims and the struggle for meaningful autonomy | ||
in Comparative American Studies , Vol. 3 n. 3 , 2005 , 283-299 | ||
There are multiple Hawaiian political claims and entitlements. Is independence appropriate for Hawai`i? Is it appropriate for Hawaiians? These two questions are not one and the same. In the movement today, there are multiple levels of ambiguity about these two claims – the right to indigenous self-determination under US domestic law and Hawai`i's right to self-determination under international law – as evidenced in the strategic invocation of both. The persistent maintenance of the dual claim reveals a particular sort of political ambivalence having to do with the dilemmas over the exercise of sovereignty in the 21st century. This article examines two different claims – one which is specific to Hawaiians as an indigenous people subjugated by US colonialism, and the other which is not limited to the indigenous and focuses on the broader national claims to Hawai`i's independence. Within this latter arena, there are two distinct lines of political activism and legal claims – one that calls for de-colonization protocols and the other that calls for deoccupation | ||