Bulletin n. 3/2010 | ||
January 2011 | ||
Mendez Fernando, Mendez Mario |
||
Comparing Privacy Regimes: Federal Theory and the Politics of Privacy Regulation in the European Union and the United States | ||
in Publius: The Journal of Federalism , vol. 40, n. 4, Fall , 2010 , 617-645 | ||
This article draws on federal theory to analyze the dynamics of crafting a privacy regime in the European Union and the United States. Three dimensions of the policy domain are analyzed: how policy was framed, the policy dynamics activated, and the policy instruments used. The main finding is that despite obvious differences in the choice of specific policy instruments, a strikingly similar regulatory dynamic and framing of policy can be detected. Two conclusions are drawn: first, federal theory can reveal novel insights on the politics of regulating privacy, especially in relation to new technologies and counter terrorism measures. Second, applying a comparative research design to EU policy-making can help explain many of its apparent empirical puzzles. | ||